吴晓林;

• 1:南开大学周恩来政府管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

技术治理,特指信息技术在治理中的应用。既往研究在泛化技术治理概念的同时,忽略了"技术与科层的互动关系"。案例研究发现,科层制自上而下地引入技术治理,推动了传统的科层组织标准化、电子化,形成有别于传统组织的特性,确实提升了科层组织的能力。同时,科层制内的技术治理更多地取决于政治逻辑而非单纯的技术逻辑,它既是科层改革的组成部分,又不可避免地受科层制的规定和制约,简而言之,技术赋能科层,科层规制技术,技术治理与科层制的关系具有"双向性"。科层体制内的技术治理是否具有系统性,往往取决于上级意志而非执行者本身,要判断技术治理是否具有整体性,就要引入"上级决策者与具体执行者"的完整链条。技术治理若受"短期行政程序改善"的预期驱动,则容易止于"内卷化"的科层同构。

关键词(KeyWords)： 技术治理;政治逻辑;科层制

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): 吴晓林;

Email:

DOI: 10.16088/j.issn.1001-6597.2020.02.007

参考文献(References)：

• [1] Mulgan,Geoff J.Communication and control:Networks and the new economies of communication[M].New York:Guilford;Mueller,1991.
• [2] Milton.Ruling the root:Internet governance and the taming of cyberspace[M].Cambridge,MA:MIT Press,2002.
• [3] 渠敬东,周飞舟,应星:从总体支配到技术治理——基于中国30年改革经验的社会学分析[J].中国社会科学,2009(6):104-127.
• [4] Grembergen W V.Strategies for information technology governance[M].Igi Global,2004.
• [5] Sambamurthy V,Zmud R W.Arrangements for information technology governance:A theory of multiple contingencies[J].MIS Quarterly,1999:261-290.
• [6] Saretzki T.Technological governance—technological citizeship?[C] //Heinelt H,Getimis P,Kafkalas G,Smith R,Swyngedouw E.Participatory governance in multi-level context.VS Verlag fürSozialwissenschaften,Wiesbaden,2002.
• [7] Okot-Uma R W’O,London C S.Electronic governance:re-inventing good governance[J].Commonwealth Secretariat,London,2000(5).
• [8] AlAwadhi S,Morris A.Factors influencing the adoption of e-government services[J].Journal of Software,2009,4(6):584-590.
• [9] Prins C.Electronic government.Variations on a concept[C]// J E J.Designing e-government.Kluwer Law International,Netherlands,2001:1-5.
• [10] Stier S.Political determinants of e-government performance revisited:Comparing democracies and autocracies[J].Government Information Quarterly,2015,32(3):270-278.
• [11] 张丙宣.政府的技术治理逻辑[J],自然辩证法通讯,2018(5):95-102.
• [12] Ahn M J,Bretschneider S.Politics of e-government:E‐government and the political control of bureaucracy[J].Public Administration Review,2011,71(3):414-424.
• [13] Cordelia A.E-government:towards the e-bureaucratic form?[J].Journal of Information Technology,2007,22(3):265-274.
• [14] Buffat A.Street-level bureaucracy and e-government[J].Public Management Review,2015,17(1):149-161.
• [15] 黄晓春,嵇欣.技术治理的极限及其超越[J].社会科学,2016(11):72-79.
• [16] 应小丽,钱凌燕.“项目进村”中的技术治理逻辑及困境分析[J].行政论坛,2015(3):93-97.
• [17] 付建军.当代中国社会治理创新的发生机制与内在张力——兼论社会治理创新的技术治理逻辑[J].当代世界与社会主义,2018(6):181-190.
• [18] 马卫红,耿旭.技术治理对现代国家治理基础的解构[J].探索与争鸣,2019(6):68-75.
• [19] 韩志明.技术治理的四重幻象——城市治理中的信息技术及其反思[J].探索与争鸣,2019(6):48-58.
• [20] Reddick G.Citizen interaction with e-government:From the streets to servers?[J].Government Information Quarterly,2005,22(1):38-57.
• [21] Jain A.Using the lens of Max Weber’s theory of bureaucracy[C]//37th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences,2004.Proceedings of the IEEE,2004:127-136.
• [22] Galperin H.Beyond interests,ideas,and technology:An institutional approach to communication and information policy[J].The Information Society,2004,20(3):159-168.
• [23] 简·E.芳汀.构建虚拟政府:信息技术与制度创新[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2010.
• [24] 马亮.政务服务创新何以降低行政负担:西安行政效能革命的案例研究[J].甘肃行政学院学报,2019(2):4-11.
• [25] 蒙克,李朔严.公共管理研究中的案例方法:一个误区和两种传承[J].中国行政管理,2019(9):89-94.
• [26] James Mahoney.The logic of process tracing tests in the social sciences[J].Sociological Methods & Research,2012(4):570-597.
• [27] 周志忍.西方发达国家是否也存在“层层加码”[J].人民论坛,2016(21):25-27.
• [28] Kim S,Jooho L.E-participation,transparency,and trust in local government[J].Public Administration Review,2012,72(6):819-828.
• [29] Moon M J,Welch E W.Same bed,different dreams?A comparative analysis of citizen and bureaucrat perspectives on e-government[J].Review of Public Personnel Administration,2005,25(3):243-264.
• [30] La Porte T M,Demchak C C,De Jong M.Democracy and bureaucracy in the age of the web:empirical findings and theoretical speculations[J].Administration & Society,2002,34(4):411-446.
• [31] Parent M,Vandebeek C A,Gemino A C.Building trust through e-government[J].Government Information Quarterly,2004,22(4):720-736.